Tested: Hammer Gel

hammer gel

Hammer Gel looks like yet another energy gel, and while it does serve the same purpose as all the others, the formula is a bit different. This gel is formulated according to Hammer Nutrition’s philosophy, so it contains no added refined, simple sugars, and no artificial colors or sweeteners. Rather, Hammer’s gel is made with real fruit and wholesome ingredients.

Hammer also offers a great variety of tasty flavors. Along with your standard fruit and coffee flavors, Hammer offers some unique flavors, including Montana Huckleberry!

Hammer Gel Nutrition and Ingredients

Hammer is probably most known for their nutrition philosophy, which permeates through all their products as well the their information booklets and website. They are really big on sticking with natural ingredients, only complex carbs (no simple sugars,) etc.

They do this to create wholesome products which provide for a smooth, consistent energy release and easy digestion.

One interesting note is that Hammer gel is Gluten-Free, Vegan Friendly, and Kosher Certified, for those who have dietary restrictions.

Here are the ingredients* for the vanilla flavor:

Ingredients: Long Chained Maltodextrin, Filtered Water, Energy SmartĀ® (Fruit Juice, Natural Grain Dextrins), Potassium Sorbate (as a preservative), Vanilla Extract, Citric Acid, Potassium Chloride, Salt, Amino Acids (L-Leucine, L-Valine, L-Alanine, L-Isoleucine).

I do like the ingredients list. It’s pretty simple and natural, but still contains everything necessary to an energy gel.

*Espresso and Tropical flavors contain caffeine.

I haven’t noticed a real difference in my health or performance when using Hammer Gel vs the others which contain simple sugars, but it’s a nice thought and makes Hammer a great option for health-conscious riders.

Hammer Gel Taste Test

Hammer gel comes in many flavors, most of which are very interesting. To me, when I think of Hammer gel, I think of the flavor selection!

Here are my thoughts on each flavor…

Apple-Cinnamon – A very strong apple cinnamon flavor, making this my favorite Hammer gel. It’s almost too strong during an intense race, but since I love apple cinnamon stuff, I really really like this one.

I could actually eat this for enjoyment. If I was buying a jug of Hammer gel, I’d get the Apple-Cinnamon, and I’d make every excuse to eat it often.

Banana – I think this tastes like a real banana. You could mistake this gel for a mashed banana in a blind taste test. Actually, it has even more banana flavor than some bananas do!

I don’t think I could eat this one all the time, but it’s a good flavor, and definitely good to have since GU no longer makes a banana flavor.

Chocolate – Starts out like a good chocolate syrup, e.g. pretty sweet and chocolaty. The flavor is neither overly sweet like Nesquik-type stuff, nor bitter like pure cocoa.

The aftertaste gets more authentic though. I wouldn’t say it’s bitter, but it’s verging on bitter, because you taste the real cocoa powder.

Espresso – Starts out tasting like a mocha gel. Maybe with a little coffee flavor in there, but it’s mainly chocolate on my taste buds.

Finally, the espresso flavor showed up in the aftertaste. I practically had the entire gel packet before getting any espresso flavor. The espresso flavor was a little bitter like it should be, but not as potent as I had hoped.

It wasn’t a bad gel, but somewhat disappointing. If you want a coffee gel, try something else (maybe Clif Shot.)

Orange – I’ve had orange gels I didn’t like, but the Orange flavor of Hammer gel is actually good. It tastes like a mix of the mandarin orange Heed and orange Kool-Aid (with an emphasis on the Kool-Aid.) It’s flavorful, but not too strong, and it’s not too sweet nor too sour.

If you like orange flavors but could never find a good orange energy gel, try this one.

Montana Huckleberry – N/A

Raspberry – This tastes very natural, almost exactly like red raspberries. It starts out very sweet, too (much sweeter than Orange.)

It’s almost too natural in a way. Since it contains real raspberry puree, it has a hint of sourness, much like you can get a bad raspberry when you pick a handful. And when it gets warm, it gets less appetizing.

It gets better after the first taste, though, so I actually do enjoy this flavor a little bit. It’s kind of like the raspberry Clif Shot – not great, but not bad if you get used to it. In cold weather, it’s actually really good.

[It's like chocolate in the way that it starts out quite sweet, but then you do notice some sourness later on.]

Tropical – I like to compare Tropical to the Apple Cinnamon flavor, because both are very good flavors that you don’t see too often. Tropical is a mix of tropical fruit flavors, such as pineapple and mango, although I couldn’t detect any one flavor from the bunch.

It was pretty sweet, but not overpowering, and had a good flavor. It wasn’t really like Hawaiian Punch, so I’m not sure how to describe it, but if you like tropical fruits, I bet you’d like this.

Vanilla – Tastes like any other vanilla gel. It has some vanilla flavor, but when riding, you just notice a mild sweetness and not much else.

If you don’t like strong or exotic flavors, the Vanilla is probably right for you.

Hammer Gel Texture and Consistency

I’d say the texture and consistency of Hammer gel is a little thinner than other gels. Hammer says the texture is like “syrup,” but I’m not sure what that means, because there are many types of syrup out there and they’re all different.

Perhaps it’s more like syrup than a gel (if you think of gel literally, like a toothpaste gel or even Jello.) The best information I can provide is that Hammer gel is thinner than GU gel.

The thinness makes it good for cold weather, because it remains a gel. (In extreme cold, GU will get real thick so you basically have to chew it, but Hammer Gel stays fairly thin.)

Hammer Gel’s Energy Boost

Unfortunately, as cool as Hammer gel seems, it never seemed to give me the energy boost that GU did. After a couple packets, I could sometimes feel a tiny boost, but not really.

Sure, the gel gives me calories that I can burn for energy, but when I take a GU gel, I just plain feel an energy boost that inspires me to ride harder. (And no, I never had the “crash and burn” from energy gels like GU, so that argument never swayed me.)

Nevertheless, I still use Hammer’s gel on occasion because of the sweet apple cinnamon flavor!

Hammer Gel Pricing and Packaging

While Hammer’s products are usually on the expensive side, the gel is fairly cheap if you buy the 26 serving jug for $18.95.

Even at $1.25 per packet, it’s no more than any other gel.

Speaking of the gel packs, Hammer has the most interesting packaging. The gel packet is shaped like a hammer! Unfortunately, while the hammer-shaped packaging is a novel idea, it’s kind of bulky, and I find the top tab a tiny bit harder to tear off than on competing gels.

Basically, it sucks to tuck these bulky packets into your shorts. It would be a much better idea to use a Hammer Gel flask. But that makes a good combo – buy the gel by the jug, and then carry it in the flask.

My final verdict is…

If you’re looking for a good gel, give this a shot. If it works for you, and you find the right flavor, great. If not, just keep looking around. (If Hammer doesn’t work for you, I recommend trying GU gel or Clif Shot.)

For me, I absolutely love the flavors, so I use Hammer gel for some training rides and things like XC skiing, but for my races, I stick with GU gel.

Official website: www.HammerNutrition.com

Buy online: www.HammerNutrition.com or www.REI.com

Tested: GU Energy Gel

gu energy gels

While I always thought $1 for a tiny gel packet was a rip-off, GU energy gel was one thing I couldn’t live without during a mountain bike race. Real food was too much of a hassle, and PowerBars just took too long to chew while navigating teeth rattling singletrack!

Every mountain bike race I did, it was a sure bet that I had at least one GU in my pocket or tucked under my shorts!

Why choose GU?

I first chose GU due to the neat name, but it turned out to be a perfect choice. First, GU comes in many flavors. You’ve got chocolate and coffee, fruity flavors, and even a “plain” flavor for those with sensitive tastebuds – surely one tastes good to you.

Just as important, the flavors actually taste good! I really like GU gels and could eat them all the time!

Next, the packets are easy to carry, easy to open, and easy to squeeze. You just tear the small tab off the top and you’re all set. There is no excess bulk to the package like with the Hammer and Clif Shot gels.

Best of all, GU gel gives me good energy boost. While all energy gels are basically the same thing (100 calories of quick energy from sugar,) there is something about GU that just makes me feel better. After having a GU, I always seem to get this uplifting feeling where I actually feel the energy returning to my body.

Other energy gels may provide me with calories, but none of them give me that energizing feeling I get with GU.

Science, Ingredients, and Nutrition

The GU website has a complete description of how GU works. I’ll summarize here.

You first get a shot of natural fructose, which will quickly build up your energy levels. That gives the maltodextrin time to be absorbed and broken down, maintaining your glucose levels for extended energy. The electrolytes and calcium keep you hydrated and make sure your blood and muscles are functioning optimally.

Branched chain amino acids (BCAAs) leucine, valine and isoleucine, serve as another fuel source, aid in recovery, and can improve mental performance and reduce fatigue. Antioxidant vitamins C & E defend muscles from assault by free radicals, while chamomile works as an anti-inflammatory. Ginger soothes the stomach, a nice bonus if the race includes gut-wrenching climbs!

Whatever the exact formula is, GU did a good job with it!

Vanilla bean ingredients:

MALTODEXTRIN (GLUCOSE POLYMERS), FILTERED WATER, FRUCTOSE, GU AMINO ACID BLEND (LEUCINE, VALINE, ISOLEUCINE, HISTIDINE), POTASSIUM AND SODIUM CITRATE, GU ANTIOXIDANT BLEND (NATURAL VITAMIN E AND VITAMIN C), SEA SALT, NATURAL VANILLA, CITRIC ACID, CALCIUM CARBONATE, SODIUM BENZOATE, POTASSIUM SORBATE, GU HERBAL BLEND [CHAMOMILE, COLA NUT (HAS CAFFEINE), GINGER], FUMARIC ACID, PECTIN

Nutrition Facts:

100 calories
55mg sodium
40mg potassium
25g carbs
3g sugar

But while you won’t get fat and protein in a GU gel, you get more than just sugar. You’ve got the antioxidants, amino acids, ginger, etc.

GU Gel Taste Test

Here are my thoughts on the eight different flavors of GU gel:

Vanilla Bean

A sweet vanilla flavor. It’s not quite a true vanilla bean flavor, but it’s not the same as imitation vanilla. Basically it’s sweet and tastes a bit like vanilla once you swallow it. I’d say it’s the sweetest GU flavor.

gu gel tri berry

Tri-Berry

Tastes mostly like red raspberry. It’s pretty sweet, too. There is a hint of strawberry in there, especially in the aftertaste, and I think that sweetens up the raspberry. I’m not sure on the third berry; probably blackberry.

It’s a good berry flavor. It used to be my favorite GU, but has since been replaced by the recently added Strawberry Banana flavor.

Chocolate Outrage

This gel is thick and chocolaty. It contains actual unsweetened Belgian chocolate. While it’s not as delicious as a chocolate bar from Belgium, and doesn’t have that melty texture like a piece of Dove chocolate, it’s like a moderately good piece of dark, bittersweet chocolate.

It’s great on a cold day when it thickens up like a chocolate milkshake. It’s messy in the summer though, so watch out.

Espresso Love

Espresso is possibly my new favorite flavor! It really does taste like espresso. The flavor comes from “natural coffee flavor” rather than actual coffee, but it pulls off a great taste regardless. If you like espresso, you will love this gel!

Just Plain

This is basically a weaker version of Vanilla Bean. It’s not flavorless like water, but it’s definitely not strong and overpowering. So while this is definitely not “plain,” it’s probably the least potent flavor of gel available.

gu gel lemon sublime

Lemon Sublime

An interesting lemon lime flavor. Each time I have one, it reminds me of something else. I just can’t compare it to anything else. It’s not too sweet, not too sour, nor too weird. I would rate it “pretty good.”

If you like lemon lime products though, you’ll probably enjoy this one.

Orange Burst

Not a realistic orange, but not totally artificial or too sugary. It reminds me of orange Gatorade. The taste is alright but nothing that blows me away.

Strawberry Banana

I always liked banana (my second favorite flavor,) so I was disappointed to see GU replace it with Strawberry Banana. But once I tried this, I was excited!

The Strawberry Banana is awesome. It is very sweet and delicious. It tastes mostly like banana but with some sweet strawberry flavor in there as well.

So Strawberry Banana actually beats out Tri-Berry and Espresso Love as my favorite flavor!

My final verdict is…

GU is my favorite gel. It tastes great, contains good ingredients, comes in good packaging, and provides the best energy boost I’ve had from a gel. All around, a perfect gel.

If you need a gel for your endurance sports adventures, GU is my recommendation.

Official website: www.GuEnergy.com

Buy online: www.REI.com | www.PerformanceBike.com

Tested: Clif Shot Energy Gel

clif shot gels

Just about every energy bar manufacturer also makes an energy gel. Clif Bar is no different – they offer Clif Shot for anyone who wants a quick shot of calories in the convenient gel form.

I’ve used Clif Shot gels a few times in the past few years, and never had great success with them, but I bought a bunch this past fall/winter season so I could perform a complete test and review.

After many hours of road riding, mountain bike racing, and XC skiing, here is what I think of Clif Shot gels…

Clif Shot Ingredients and Nutrition Facts

Let’s start by looking at the ingredients list of a Clif Shot gel:

Strawberry: Organic Brown Rice Syrup, Organic Strawberry Puree, Sea Salt, Citric Acid, Organic and Natural Flavors, Green Tea Extract (contains caffeine), Potassium Citrate, Magnesium Oxide.

The first thing you notice is that Clif uses brown rice syrup instead of the more popular maltodextrin (brown rice syrup is also the first ingredient in Clif Bars.) I don’t consider either one to be any better or worse than the other as far as healthiness goes, so if you like brown rice syrup, great.

The other interesting ingredient is strawberry puree. Clif seems to use some ‘real’ ingredients in their gel to give it that natural flavor. I do appreciate how they choose the more natural and organic ingredients.

The Nutrition Facts go a little something like this:

Calories 100
Fat 0g
Total Carbs 25g
Sugars 8g
Protein 0g
Sodium 40mg
Potassium 30mg

That’s your standard energy gel right there. It focuses on carbs, contains no fat or protein, and has a few electrolytes. Nothing more to say about that.

Clif Shot Taste Test and Review

Here are my thoughts on all the Clif Shot flavors.

clif shot strawberry

Sonic Strawberry – Starts with a natural strawberry flavor, probably due to the “strawberry puree” in there. It’s a decent flavor, but a little too ‘natural’ for me.

Also, after maybe half the gel, I notice a metallic taste. (I’m not sure how to best describe it, but some weird tinge is in there that I didn’t like.) Or maybe you could call it a chemical/artificial taste, despite the organic ingredients and natural flavors.

Strawberry has 25mg caffeine.

Razz Sorbet – This was the first Clif Shot flavor I ever tried. It’s not bad at all; it’s quite a bit better than strawberry.

Razz has a similar natural taste like the strawberry, except this tastes like real raspberry. It’s pretty sweet, with no aftertaste. It’s still not as good as Tri Berry GU, but it’s edible.

Cola – This sounded kind of weird, but it wasn’t bad at all. I don’t even like cola or any soda, so I was surprised to like this at all.

This was a very interesting flavor – probably one of those “love it or hate it” ones. Apparently they quit making this flavor though, so there must not have been much ‘love’ for it.

Apple Pie – Finally, a good tasting flavor! This tastes quite a bit like apple pie, but not too sweet (a good thing.) It has that natural apple taste like other Clif Shot flavors, but this time there is no aftertaste!

Apple Pie is probably my favorite Shot. As for flavor, it’s not quite as good as the apple cinnamon Hammer gel, but it’s worth trying if you like apple.

Double Espresso – [Review coming soon.]

Double Espresso contains 100mg caffeine, like a “double” shot of espresso.

clif shot mocha

Mocha – Even though I don’t care for chocolate flavored energy bars, chocolate energy gels are a different story. Especially this mocha Clif shot, which is awesome! (I’d say this is my favorite of all chocolate energy gels.)

It has a very natural taste since it contains actual cocoa powder – it’s like real chocolate. It’s not bitter though, thanks to the sweetness of the brown rice syrup.

Mocha contains 50mg caffeine.

Mango – This tastes like a real mango, but not a ripe one. It’s not sweet, and it’s not sour, but it’s just plain bad. It was so awful I could barely finish the whole gel packet! (The aftertaste was bad too – I had to consume a strawberry gel after this just to get the taste out of my mouth as quickly as possible!)

While I don’t think any of the fruit flavored Clif Shot gels are good, the strawberry and razz are like delicacies compared to the Mango! Avoid the mango flavor unless you’re a true masochist!

Overall, you can taste the natural fruit purees (or cocoa) used in these gels. That’s not so bad. But that real puree mixed with whatever else is in these gels does not make for a good final product.

I think Clif Bars taste pretty good, but the gel is another story. Except for the Mocha (their chocolate-flavored gel,) I’m not a fan of Clif Shot gels.

Texture:

The Clif Shot texture is sort of different than the other gels, probably because of the brown rice syrup. It gets quite thin in the heat, which I don’t really like. Fortunately, it’s nice and thick in the cold weather.

It turned out great for XC skiing. But I also did an XC mountain bike race in 92 degree heat with these. A pack goes down in 2 seconds it’s so thin! (At that point, you barely even taste it, which could be good or bad, depending on your preference.)

Clif Shot Energy Boost

I did get a small but noticeable energy boost with these. Roughly 5 minutes after consuming one I noticed I felt stronger. It was not as good of a boost as GU gel, but it was a little better boost than with Hammer gel.

(Of course, I wanted another one after 45 minutes or so; same as any 100 calorie energy gel.)

I got a pretty heavy caffeine kick from the Mocha, and that only has 50mg caffeine! With 100mg caffeine, the Double Espresso should be pretty potent!

The Litter Leash

To show their environmental concern, Clif came up with something called the Litter Leash. This is a design where you can tear off the top of the gel pack but still leave it attached! It prevents the inevitable litter from many people who drop the little tops of gel packs along the road or trail.

However, I have found that standard GU gel packets are easier to open and less bulky. And since I don’t mind saving the tab and sticking it in my jersey pocket, GU is great for me.

To make matters worse, the litter leash doesn’t always work. Since the packet is pretty hard to open, sometimes I have to pull it hard enough that the litter leash rips right off, rendering it useless.

My final verdict is…

I won’t be switching from GU gels, but it’s worth trying a Clif Shot to see if it works better for you. I’d recommend a raspberry or apple pie flavor if you like fruit, or the Mocha or Double Espresso if you’re adventurous.

(For me, GU is easier to open, tastes better, and starts working faster, so I will stick with them.)

Official website: www.ClifShot.com

Buy online: www.PerformanceBike.com

Quick Comparison: Top 10 Energy Gels

While most energy gels are practically the same thing, there are subtle differences with each one. Here is a quick comparison chart that shows nutrition facts from the top ten most popular energy gels:

  Serving Size Calories Carbs Protein Sodium Potassium Caffeine Price
Accel Gel 41g 100 20g 5g 100mg 50mg 0 $1.67
GU 32g 100 25g 0 55mg 45mg Yes $1.35
Power Gel 42g 110 27g 0 200mg 20mg 0 $1.25
Clif Shot 32g 100 25g 0 40mg 30mg 0 $1.00
Hammer Gel 36g 90 23g 0 25mg n/a 0 $1.25
Honey Stinger 37g 120 29g 0 50mg 85mg 0 $1.25
Carb Boom! 41g 110 27g 0 50mg 50mg 0 $1.25
Sharkies Chews 45g 140 36g 0 110mg 30mg 0 $1.50
Enervit 25ml (24g) 71 18g 0 n/a n/a 0 $1.89
e-Gel 55g 150 37g 0 220mg 80mg 0 $1.49

* Figures come from company websites as of 7/1/09. Values based on the vanilla flavor. (Except Honey Stinger, which is based on “Gold” flavor, and Sharkies, which is based on “Citrus.”)

You can find more information at the respective company websites:

I encourage you to visit these websites and check out the flavors, ingredients, and other information before buying. This was just a quick comparison chart; there is much more research to do.

Also note that most figures in the chart will apply to all flavors in the line of gels, but not always. Take caffeine for example. Most gels do offer some flavors with caffeine, even if the vanilla flavor (listed here) has no added caffeine.

Also, while most gels use maltodextrin and dextrose for the sugar, one gel listed here actually contains High Fructose Corn Syrup. Always read the ingredients before making a purchase!

Want my opinion on the gels?

See my reviews:

How NOT To Carry Energy Gels During a Marathon

nyc marathon runners

If you are running a marathon or other endurance event, there’s a good chance you need to carry food with you. Sometimes you need to carry food and water, but most events provide water and Gatorade on the course, so food is the primary concern.

I prefer to carry energy gels with me by pinning them to my shorts, but there are many other ways you can try.

Here are 7 of those ways: (The catch is, you do NOT want to carry your gels like this!)

1. Gels under your race cap.

If you wear a running cap, you could put the gels underneath the cap so they are held in place between the hat and the top of your head.

But gel packets on your head isn’t very comfortable, and you also have to make sure the gels don’t fall onto the ground whenever you remove the cap!

2. Gels under a forearm sweat band.

I like wrist/forearm sweatbands so I can easily wipe sweat from my brow, but I wouldn’t use them to hold gels against my arm.

Gel packets are slippery, especially against skin, and they could easily slide out from underneath the sweatband.

3. Tape gels to your body.

To make sure the gels aren’t going anywhere, you could just tape them to your body. That will certainly hold them in place, but removing them is not comfortable, especially if you have body hair!

4. Glue gels to your body.

If you’re out of tape, don’t worry – you can glue the gel packets to your body! Of course, this makes for even more painful removal, since a layer of your skin will rip off with the gel packet!

5. Clothes pins around your waistband.

If you’re out of safety pins, maybe you have some wooden clothes pins lying around? You could clamp some gels to your waistband with these pins.

You just have to deal with the discomfort of a big wooden object pressing against your body, and the good possibility that the gel will slide right out of its grasp.

6. Sew your own Velcro holders.

If you are good with needle and thread (and glue,) you could make your own Velcro attachment system. Simply sew Velcro patches onto your shorts, then glue the corresponding Velcro to your gel packs.

That’s pretty secure and allows for an easy grab, but why waste good Velcro on gel packs that will be thrown away?

7. Wear a triathlon singlet.

By far the easiest way to carry gels when running would be to wear a triathlon singlet (those fancy skin-tight tank tops.) It has a neat little pocket in the back where you could stow a few gels.

But triathlon gear has no place being worn during a marathon! Outside of triathlons, you shouldn’t, you know, look like a triathlete…

Photo credit: Penningtron

Next Page »