Why The Bosu Ball Gets a Bad Rap
Never seen a Bosu ball? Imagine taking a Swiss ball, cutting it in half, and mounting a platform on the cut side. It’s an interesting device, sort of like a wobble board.
But as neat looking as it is, nine out of ten strength training or fitness websites you go to, if the Bosu ball is mentioned, it’s only to make fun of the thing! It just seems most strength training coaches and bodybuilders hate the Bosu ball, not to mention their feelings toward personal trainers who include Bosu ball exercises in their so-called “functional training” fitness plans in the big commercial gyms.
But why do they hate it so much?
I think the problem lies not with the Bosu ball itself, but with the way in which people use it.
Background on Training Methods
To illustrate my point, let’s first review a few different training methods:
- Weight lifting
- Bodyweight exercises
- Balance training
Weight lifting involves lifting heavy weights in order to gain muscle and/or strength. The object is to move as much weight as possible, which requires a very stable base – feet flat on floor, body tight, etc.
Bodyweight exercises involve moving your body through space. There are no extra weights for resistance; instead, you move your body in ways that are progressively more difficult. The object of this style training is typically to increase full-body strength without gaining extra muscle.
Balance training is typically used by athletes such as skiiers, snowboarders, gymnasts, martial artists, freestyle BMX riders, mountain bikers, etc. If you need to balance on something in weird positions to excel in your sport, you should be training to improve your balance. This type of training can be done without equipment, but it commonly includes the use of the Swiss ball, wobble boards, balance boards, and yes, the Bosu ball.
Why Diss The Bosu Ball?
I think most can agree with those statements on training methods. So why diss the Bosu ball?
Because some trainers are combining weight lifting and balance training together.
I’m not sure why they do this. My best guesses are 1) they can say it’s time efficient for your busy schedule, and 2) it sounds new and exciting, which probably appeals to many gym-goers.
But if you step back and think, weight lifting and balance training have completely different goals. Weight lifting is all about heavy weights. But, you simply can’t use heavy weights when standing precariously on a Bosu ball. So you can’t realistically make the gains you want. And worrying about adding weights during balance training seems useless. I don’t know about you, but I’ve never seen a snowboarder or gymnast holding weights during an event.
Sure, doing squats with 300lb on your back while balancing on a Bosu ball could be a neat circus trick, but it’s not the most practical exercise. Spend your time doing something productive. It doesn’t need to be fancy to get results.
When it comes down to it, I agree that mixing weight lifting and balance training is pretty stupid. But that doesn’t mean I hate the Bosu ball!
How the Bosu Ball Can Be Useful
When it comes to improving balance, especially if you’re still working your way up to standing on a stability ball, the Bosu ball can be a useful tool. You can think of it like training wheels for riding a bike, or as another tool in your toolbox.
To see examples of Bosu ball exercises, take a look at this Bosu ball exercise page at AskTheTrainer.com. It shows some common uses of the Bosu ball. Note that I don’t recommend all those exercises, but in general, that is more in line with what the Bosu ball should be used for.
As long as you stick with using it for balance training, rehab, and as a Swiss ball replacement for some core exercises – such as, a plank with your elbows up on the Bosu ball – you’ll be fine.
Lance Armstrong Used a Bosu Ball!
Just wanted to point this out for fun – Lance Armstrong was spotted using a Bosu ball. It was in the February 2009 issue of Men’s Health magazine.
In one photo, it appears as though Lance is just using the ball and doing lateral jumps over it. But in the other, he is doing push-ups with one hand on the ball. That’s a good exercise, although it can be done with a medicine ball or soccer ball.
Why I Wouldn’t Buy a Bosu Ball
Even though I just said the Bosu ball can be useful, I have no plans to buy one, nor do I recommend you go out and purchase one.
First, the things cost $80-120. That is a lot! A stability ball will cost you less than $20.
Second, most of the time you could use a Bosu ball, you might as well just use a stability ball anyway.
Note: If the stability ball seems too intimidating to work with, just don’t inflate it so much. I think most people would be fine just getting a cheap, small Swiss ball and using it half-inflated when necessary. That’s a decent Bosu ball replacement while you improve your balance enough to use the stability ball as intended.
Final Word on the Bosu Ball
You know the saying, “Guns don’t kill people, people kill people.” ?
I adopt a similar stance in favor of the Bosu ball: “Bosu balls don’t make people do stupid exercises. Stupid personal trainers make people do stupid exercises.”
It is less eloquent and takes many more words, but it gets the point across. You can’t blame the Bosu ball for how people use it. While I don’t recommend the Bosu ball for everyone, it doesn’t need to be shunned and laughed at.
Posted January 20, 2011
Comments(2)

Enter your name and email below to get a free copy of the "7 Nutrition Mistakes Most Endurance Athletes Make" e-book!



